The Secret Healer by Ellin Carsta Review | Kieran Higgins

The Secret Healer by Ellin Carsta – Review

The Secret HealerThe Secret Healer by Ellin Carsta
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

I gave up before reaching the climax. The language was horribly anachronistic (though this may be a translation issue) and the author’s approach to showing and telling was frightfully inconsistent. Large, important crucial moments are glossed over in seconds, while pages are devoted to the most trivial of the protagonist’s musings or experience.

And the plots go beyond drama to sheer melodrama. It is impossible to feel any sympathy for the protagonist as most of the stuff that goes wrong in her life is a direct result of her own actions and foolishness i.e continuing to practice healing when she has seen at least three times how dangerous its, trusting stupid people who’ve betrayed her trust before. And we’re supposed to believe she discovered hypnotism and it’s effective in labour in the C14th?

She’s also a bit of Mary Sue, learning healing quickly, almost without instruction and then learns the art of fine sewing in next to no time?

View all my reviews


Psst! Want great books delivered to your home each month? Get 10% off the Willoughby Book Club here (affiliate):

The Willoughby Book Club

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *